Skip to content
South African Live
Menu
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Business
  • About us
Menu

Impeachment committee could face fresh delay as EFF considers challenge to court ruling on evidence leader

Posted on November 17, 2026
25

Parliament’s Impeachment Committee into whether President Cyril Ramaphosa should be removed from office over the February 2020 burglary at his Phala Phala game farm could face further delays, depending on whether the EFF goes ahead with a challenge to the Western Cape High Court’s dismissal of its application.

An EFF insider says the party is considering an appeal.

The committee was planning to move forward this week, to adopt its terms of reference and nominate a chief evidence leader.

EFF parliamentary spokesperson Andiswa Madikazi had not confirmed nor denied the appeal after Africa Daily sent questions on Tuesday morning.

Committee chairperson Makashule Gana said on Sunday the committee plans to meet this Friday to nominate a new evidence leader and finalise its terms of reference.

He said the committee will not start the process from scratch but will consider a candidate from the names it already received.

“If there is an additional person that could be nominated, we will include them,” he said.

Gana added that at Friday’s meeting, the committee is expected to adopt the “final, final draft” of its terms of reference.

On Friday, Gana welcomed the court’s dismissal of the EFF and the African Legal Professionals Association (ALPA) applications over the evidence leader decision.

The impeachment inquiry, provided for by Section 89 of the Constitution, has been delayed in recent months by legal challenges and court interdicts.

In August, the Impeachment Committee recommended Advocate Thandazani Madonsela SC as chief evidence leader for the inquiry.

Ramaphosa objected to Madonsela’s appointment, citing potential conflicts of interest, including that he had previously removed Madonsela from the Judicial Services Commission (JSC) in 2022 and that Madonsela had previously provided legal advice to an ANC study group on the impeachment process.

The committee voted to rescind its recommendation of Madonsela and reversed his nomination.

That decision prompted the EFF and ALPA to approach the court, arguing that the committee acted in bad faith when it backtracked on Madonsela’s recommendation.

Delivering judgment last Friday, Judge Chantel Fortuin said the full bench was divided, but the majority had dismissed both applications.

“It follows from the discussion set out above that neither application establishes a ground of review, and the question of remedy does not arise. I record only that both applicants accept that an order in their favour would not have appointed Adv Madonsela SC. Counsel for ALPA readily accepted that on a remittal the committee could rationally have decided either way. Nothing in this judgment decides who should be the committee’s evidence leader, or prevents any party from nominating any practitioner in the reopened process,” said Fortuin.

Gana said that after the committee rescinded Madonsela’s name, political parties were invited to make further nominations, but they did not make any new nominations, “which means that we have to consider those that had originally been nominated and were available”.

Among the candidates for evidence leader were Adv Zinzile Matebese SC, Adv Kate Hofmeyer SC, Adv Vuyani Ngalwana SC, Adv Ismail Jamie SC, Adv Pule Seleka SC, and Adv Taki Madima SC, who was not available before November.

The committee heard at the time that, while they were nominated, Advocates Marumo Moerane SC and Doron Goldberg SC were not available.

Recent Posts

  • BREAKING NEWS 18-YEAR-OLD ARRESTED WITH DRUGS WORTH OVER R8 MILLION IN MARGAT…
  • Impeachment committee could face fresh delay as EFF considers challenge to court ruling on evidence leader
  • Tributes Pour In for Award-Winning eNCA Journalist Nabeelah Shaikh
  • GTA 6 Breaks Internet Traffic Record Before Launch
  • MKP keeps cards close on eThekwini coalition talks amid speculation of ANC deal

First established in 2020 by iReport Media Group, southafricanlive.co.za has evolved to become one of the most-read websites in South Africa. Published by iReport Media Group since 2020, find out all about us right here.

We bring you the latest breaking news updates, from South Africa and the African continent. South African Live is an independent, no agenda and no bias online news disruptor that goes beyond the news and behind the headlines. We believe what sets us apart is that we deliver news differently. While we hold ourselves to the utmost journalistic integrity of being truthful, we encourage a writing style that is acerbic and conversational, when appropriate.

LATEST NEWS

  • BREAKING NEWS 18-YEAR-OLD ARRESTED WITH DRUGS WORTH OVER R8 MILLION IN MARGAT…
  • Impeachment committee could face fresh delay as EFF considers challenge to court ruling on evidence leader
  • Tributes Pour In for Award-Winning eNCA Journalist Nabeelah Shaikh
  • GTA 6 Breaks Internet Traffic Record Before Launch
  • MKP keeps cards close on eThekwini coalition talks amid speculation of ANC deal

Menu

  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Fashion
  • Sports
  • About us
©2026 South African Live | Design: Newspaperly WordPress Theme