A former National Arts Council (NAC) chief executive has accused acting CFO Reshma Bhoola of giving Parliament a false account of how R65 million left the NAC’s bank account.
Marion Mbina-Mthembu, the NAC’s interim CEO from September 2021 to August 2022, says she never knew about the transfers.
In a letter seen by Africa Daily, she said that the payments were made without the council’s approval.
She further explained that the money was Covid-19 relief meant for artists, not surplus funds.
“It remains my conclusion that the funds transferred to the Reserve Bank were not a surplus of the NAC, but funds meant for Covid-19 relief,” she wrote.
“The NAC finance manager deliberately misled Exco and Council in stating that it was surplus funds of the NAC,” she wrote.
Her letter, dated 10 November, is addressed to the chair of the Portfolio Committee on Sport, Arts and Culture and copied to Sport, Arts and Culture Minister Gayton McKenzie.
On Tuesday, 10 November, Bhoola told the committee that the first R5 million was moved in October 2021 “with the approval of myself, as I was the acting CFO at the time, and a verbal discussion with the CEO at the time”.
She said the CFO at the time then authorised R60 million in March 2022, under a National Treasury directive.
Asked whether the council had passed a resolution, Bhoola said: “I’m not sure how to answer that.”
Mbina-Mthembu, who started at the NAC on 12 September 2021, says she only found out about the Reserve Bank account on 29 July 2022.
“This meant that the former acting CFO, Reshma Bhoola, deliberately withheld this information from myself, Exco and the Council,” she wrote.
She says Bhoola told her she acted alone.
“She had obtained no authority internally, and funds were redirected from the call account at ABSA as per her own emailed instructions to her team,” Mbina-Mthembu wrote.
She lists the transfers as R5 million on 12 November 2021 and two tranches of R30 million each on 30 March 2022.
“Whilst there was an interim CFO, Reshma gave the instructions without his knowledge or consent, bypassing myself and Council. The CEO of the NAC has delegations to pay or transfer funds up to R2 million. Any amounts above R2 million require Council authorisation,” she wrote.
She says much of the money came from DSAC for artists.
“The R41 million transfer from the Department of Sport, Arts and Culture was in the main for the third-wave Covid-19 support to artists, and was thus not for NAC operations and could not be defined as a surplus or reserve,” she wrote.
Mbina-Mthembu says she reported the matter to then council chair Celenhle Dlamini and Exco.
A council committee chair later called for an external investigation. Before her acting term ended on 31 August 2022, she asked Bhoola to depose to an affidavit on the transfers.
EFF MP Eugene Mthethwa held up that affidavit in Tuesday’s meeting.
“We know she didn’t know about it. That’s why she wrote requesting the report. The affidavit is here as proof,” he said.
Julie Diphofa, who became acting CEO after Mbina-Mthembu, told MPs: “I was not privy to that information.”
