When Stardom Can’t Save a Script
Kim Kardashian has built an empire out of reality TV, fashion, business, and social media stardom, but sometimes even the brightest celebrity light can’t illuminate a shaky script. Her latest venture, the Ryan Murphy-produced series All’s Fair, recently landed with a thud, debuting at a dismal 0% on Rotten Tomatoes.
Set in an all-female divorce law firm, the series promised star power with a cast including Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash-Betts, Glenn Close, Sarah Paulson, Teyana Taylor, and of course, Kardashian herself. On paper, it looked like a recipe for success. On screen… not so much.
It’s very sad that #AllsFair is being victimized by sexism. It’s a show that isn’t afraid to be bad, it reminded me of old ABC dramas. It’s a very fun show to watch because it’s over-the-top and bad without apprehension, and that’s fantastic. pic.twitter.com/J2R8INdVF2
— jurídico harry potter (@viniciuxsz) November 5, 2025
Critics: Star Power Isn’t Enough
Despite the heavyweight cast, critics were merciless. Many pointed to a thin plot, uneven writing, and flat performances. Kardashian’s acting, in particular, became a lightning rod for commentary. Some described her delivery as emotionless, lacking inflection, and failing to bring the drama to life, even in scenes designed to be sexy or intense.
One review noted: “It’s all just painfully hard to watch … it’s beneath everyone involved, even Kardashian, who mostly seems bored. The absurdity occasionally earns a guffaw, but it’s not enough to offset the tedium.”
Industry insiders point out that Kardashian is stepping into acting without formal training, balancing lines, scenes, and her ongoing business empire, often with minimal sleep. It’s a tall order, and critics suggest that All’s Fair may simply ask too much of her.
“All’s Fair may boast a harrowing 0 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, but at least Sarah Paulson is giving it 100 percent.” PERIOD! pic.twitter.com/w9spgnTsC1 https://t.co/61V6QauGqq
— sarah paulson’s pr (@sarahpaulsbean) November 5, 2025
Fans Fight Back
Not everyone was ready to write off the show entirely. Some social media users took to X (formerly Twitter) to defend the series, framing it as fun, over-the-top entertainment rather than serious drama.
-
@viniciuxsz tweeted: “#AllsFair is being victimised by sexism. It’s a show that isn’t afraid to be bad; it reminded me of old ABC dramas. Over-the-top and fun!”
-
Another fan added: “All’s Fair may boast a harrowing 0% on Rotten Tomatoes, but at least Sarah Paulson is giving it 100%. PERIOD!”
These reactions highlight a cultural trend: audiences are often more forgiving when celebrity-driven shows embrace camp or style over substance.
Fashion Over Script
Even critics agreed that the wardrobe department deserves applause. From daring outfits to carefully curated hairstyles and makeup, Kardashian and her co-stars brought a visual flair that rivaled the dramatic shortcomings of the series. Fans and fashion followers alike praised the costumes, proving that in Hollywood, style can sometimes steal the spotlight when substance falls short.
All’s Fair is a cautionary tale for celebrity-led projects: star power alone can’t rescue a weak script. Kim Kardashian’s foray into scripted drama illustrates both the allure and pitfalls of branching out into acting. Critics may have been harsh, but fans are still engaging, debating, and enjoying the show for what it is—a campy, star-studded legal drama.
At the end of the day, All’s Fair reminds even the biggest names that staying in your lane has its merits, but it also proves that fame and resilience can turn criticism into conversation, keeping the spotlight where Kardashian knows it best: on herself.
Source: IOL
Featured Image: X{@Tele7jours}